Representation of Identities in TV Documentaries: A Discourse Analytical Approach to Documentaries Related to Ashraf and Hoveyda

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant Prof. in Sociology, Shahid Beheshti Uni.

Abstract
This study aims to conduct discourse analysis of the representation of identities in documentaries broadcast by IRIB. It focuses on two important documentaries: Ashraf and Hoveyda. The theoretical approach rests on constructivism, representation, and discourse analysis and the method is Fairclough’s Critical Discourse Analysis. The results indicate that Ashraf’s identity is represented by power, wealth, lust, courage, aristocracy, loyalty to the Shah, psychological complexes, being devoid of love, and conflict with other court women. Power, wealth, and lust are the most important ones. Also, the Hoveyda’s identity is represented by Bahaism, corruption, nonchalance towards national sentiments and being pro-American, and having logistician and dual personality. Some of these signifiers are in contrast with anti-Pahlavi macro-discourse and some are compatible with it. Finally, in these two documentaries, there is no topical cohesion, which leads to contradictory narratives. Comparing these two documentary shows reveals that they share some contradictions in representing the identities of discursive agents.

Keywords


Abrahamian, E. (1998). Iran between two revolutions (Golmohammadi, A. & Fatahi, M. E. trans.). Tehran: Ney Pub. (Original Work Published 1982).
Azimi, F. (1993). The Crisis of Democracy in Iran (1941-1943) (Houshang Mahdavi, A. & Nozari, B. Trans.). Tehran: Alborz Pub.
Dahlgren, P. (2001). Television and the Public Sphere: Citizenship, Democracy and the Media (Shafaghati, M. Trans.). Tehran: Soroush Pub. (Original Work Published 1995).
Daniali, A. (2016). Secularism, the hegemonic discourse of the program Pargar. Tehran: Directorate General of Strategic Media Research.
Eslamieh, M. (2013). Memories of Taj-almolouk. Tehran: Ney Pub.
Fairclough, N. (2011). Critical discourse analysis [Critical discourse analysis and ‎language and power] (Shayesteh Piran, F. Trans.). Tehran: Bureau of Media Studies and Planning. (Original works published 1995 and 1989).
Foran, J. (1998). ‎Fragile resistance: Social transformation in Iran from 1500 to the revolution (Tadayon, A. Trans.). Tehran: Cultural Service of Rasa.
Forghani, M. M. & Akbarzadeh Jahromi, S. J. (2011). Presenting a model for Critical Discourse Analysis of Movies. Journal of Culture-Communication Studies, 12 (16).
Forghani, M. M. (2003). The Long Way of Transition: The Development of Political Discourse in Iran. Islamic culture and thought Pub.
Goudarzi, M. & Mahdizadeh, S. M. (2013). Iran’s Islamic Revolution Ideology Representation in Washington Post in 1980 and 2010. Journal of Audio and visual media, 9 (20).
Hambly, G. (2005). The Cambridge History of Iran; Dictatorship of Mohammad Reza Shah (1941-1971) (Saghebfar, M. Trans.). Vol. 7. Tehran: Jami Pub.
Jorgensen, M. & Phillips, L. (2010). Discourse analysis as theory and method (Jalili, H. Trans.). Tehran: Ney Pub. (Original Work Published 2002).
Katuzian, M. A. (2001). Conflict between government and nation (Tayeb, A. R. Trans.). Tehran: Ney Pub.
Katuzian, M. A. (2012). The political economy of modern Iran: despotism and pseudo - modernism, 1926 – 1979 (Nafisi, M. R. & Azizi, K. Trans.). Tehran: Markaz Pub.
Kinzer, S. (2017). ‎All the Shah's men: an American coup and the roots of Middle East terror (Khajian, Sh. Trans.). Tehran: Akhtaran Pub. (Original Work Published 2003).
Mahdizadeh, S.M. (2000). Media and representation. Bureau of Media Studies and Planning Pub.
Mahdizadeh, S.M. (2001). Negative imagination of the Islamic and the Eastern nations in Western media. Journal of Rasaneh, 12 (3).
Mahdizadeh, S.M. (2015). Discourse Analysis of BBC Persian’s “Pargar”. Journal of Culture-Communication Studies, 16 (31).
Milner, A. (2006). Contemporary cultural theory: an introduction (Mohammadi, J. Trans.). Tehran: Ghoghnoos Pub. (Original Work Published 2002).
Mohammad Mehdi Forghani, Hossein Basirian Jahromi, Sara Mahdavi (2015). A Study on Membership Categorization of BBC Persian TV: (A Discourse Analysis Approach towards Pargar Programs, focusing on Religious Subjects). Journal of Culture-Communication Studies, 16 (29), 73-99.
Perrier, R. (2005). The Cambridge History of Iran; Iranian Oil Industry (Saghebfar, M. Trans.). Vol. 7. Tehran: Jami Pub.
Saikal, A. (2005). The Cambridge History of Iran; Foreign Policy of Iran (Saghebfar, M. Trans.). Vol. 7. Tehran: Jami Pub.
Sepehri, M. B. (2018). Representation of Iran in the United States Television News; Critical discourse analysis of CNN and NBC about nuclear dealing between Iran and 5+1. Journal of Communication Research, 25 (3).
Soltani, A. A. (2005). Power, discourse and language (Power mechanisms in Islamic Republic of Iran). Tehran: Ney Pub.
Williams, K. (2007). Understanding media theory (Ghasemian, R. trans.). Tehran: Saghi Pub. (Original Work Published 2003).
Yavari, B. (2014). Representing the Islamic Revolution in Farsi-language Satellite TV Documents: A Case Study of the Documentaries of Manoto and Persian BBC. (M.A. thesis). Communication Department, IRIB University.
Yazdaninasab, M. (2018). Representation of the IRIB Programs. Tehran: IRIB research center.

  • Receive Date 24 June 2019
  • Revise Date 22 August 2019
  • Accept Date 21 October 2019